Former labour councillor says ‘sensible’ people have abandoned the party

Sensible people have long ago abandoned the Hastings and Rye branch of the Labour Party.

That’s the view of Hastings Borough councillor Dany Louise who quite the party in February, driven out she said because Labour had become a ‘welcoming environment for antisemities’.

Hastings Borough Councillor Dany Louise who quit the Labour Party last month.

When, earlier this week, Hastings MP Amber Rudd called for Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn and his deputy Tom Watson to put the Hastings and Rye Constituency Labour Party (CLP) under ‘special behavioural measures’ for what she described as, ‘flagrant acts of Jew baiting,’ Ms Louise responded saying: “Yes this should happen. Sensible Labour people have long abandoned Hastings and Rye CLP to the loony and antisemitic left.”

However the man who chairs the local Labour party, Ken Maitland, rejects the criticism of the local branch saying it is, ‘vibrant, welcoming and diverse’ and he says Hastings and Rye Labour Party is ‘absolutely committed’ to fighting racism and antisemitism.

He says: “Anti-semites are a tiny minority within our party of over half a million people but one anti-semite is too many.

“We are very pleased to have a close relationship with members of the local Jewish community and the many active Jewish members in our CLP. We will always ensure our meetings are welcoming, comradely and without any discrimination.”

On Thursday (February 28th) the Hastings and Rye CLP approved a motion that called for the reinstatement of MP Chris Williamson, suspended from the Labour Party for alleged antisemitic remarks a move Ms Rudd said at the time showed the local Labour branch was, ‘…infected with antisemitism.”

The Hastings and Rye CLP’s motion called for the ‘immediate and unconditional’ reinstatement of Mr Williamson. It went on to attack those who have recently left the party which – as well as a number of high-profile national party figures – includes Ms Louise who quit three weeks ago saying the ‘level of denial’ by Jeremy Corbyn supporters over Labour’s antisemitism problem left her ‘in despair’.

Screen Shot 2019-03-04 at 07.41.26
A definition of antisemitism.

The Hastings and Rye CLP motion says: “…these figures, some who ‘love the party’ but protested against its alleged ‘institutional antisemitism’ walked out and their co-thinkers who stayed have launched outrageous slanders but have faced no charges for bringing the party in to disrepute.”

Local activists say that ‘crying wolf’ over antisemitism could cause ‘valid warnings’ to go unheard and does ‘no service to Jews’, it says: “Such cheap exploitation as a political football is also deeply shameful.”

“We believe that this orchestrated campaign now rising to a crescendo with staged resignations… suggests that accusations of antisemitism are being criminally mis-used in an unscrupulous way to destroy the Corbyn-led Labour Party,” the motion concludes.

Labour’s prospective parliamentary candidate for Hastings is Peter Chowney and he told Hastings In Focus on Sunday that the motion was moved by a Jewish party member who felt strongly about the current situation and the treatment of Chris Williamson. He said however, that it was an ‘internal party motion’ which he understood had been addressed to the Labour Party General Secretary Jennie Formby.

On the wider issues of antisemitism within the party Mr Chowney said: “I have never experienced any antisemitism in the Hastings and Rye Labour Party and no complaints of any member of the local party about antisemitism have ever been made, as far as I know.

“I understand it has happened elsewhere though, in terms of Labour Party members making antisemitic statements on social media in particular and where it does, it should be dealt with through the Labour Party’s disciplinary process. That process has in the past been rather slow and opaque, but I understand that the backlog of disciplinary hearings and complaints – about all sorts of things, not just antisemitism – has been cleared and complaints are being addressed more swiftly.”

Ms Rudd says: “Jewish people in Hastings and Rye deserve far better than a local Labour Party obsessed with peddling conspiracy theories about Jewish people. For too long the Labour Party in Hastings and Rye has deliberately goaded and baited Jews with hateful language and got away with it.

“This latest salvo is a disgrace and shows that the local Party is infected with antisemitism. I know there are Labour Party members and councillors in Hastings who are appalled by this. They need to raise their voices and Jeremy Corbyn and Tom Watson must immediately place the CLP under special behavioural measures and personally oversee efforts to treat this infection.”

Supporting her accusations Ms Rudd says the weekend’s motion is the latest in a series of antisemitic issues emerging from the local Labour Party. She highlights the case of  Michelle Harris, shortlisted as Labour candidate for Hastings and Rye, who was pulled out of the race after she drew comparisons between Israel and the Nazis, she had written: “I have often said the Holocaust victims who died with dignity must be turning in their graves at the horrors done in the name of Judaism. Gaza is a ghetto being shelled.”

Screen Shot 2019-03-04 at 07.53.05
From February 14th

When Ms Louise, councillor for the Old Hastings ward, quit the party last month she said Labour had become a ‘welcoming environment for antisemities’.

She went on: “Decent people hold their hands up in horror when the victims tell them they are being antisemitic.

“People and institutions who are sincere about not being racist learn to change their attitudes, behaviour and procedures for the better. They recognise that they have rightly been called out for unacceptable behaviour.”

One member of Hastings and Rye Labour party told Hastings In Focus she thought the local party’s action was ‘disgraceful’ while one life-long Labour voter told us: “I just don’t understand why they have got involved in this way. It’s hard for me to say this but it makes it very difficult for me to consider voting Labour again.”

2 thoughts on “Former labour councillor says ‘sensible’ people have abandoned the party

  1. As a Jewish member of the Hastings and Rye Labour Party, I can categorically state that I have not come across a single incident of anti-Semitism and on the contrary to the article which repetitively overstated Rudd and Louise comments, I have found the Hastings and Rye Labour Party a very friendly, welcoming and diverse membership. Amber Rudd has no right to make such defamatory remarks about the people of Hastings and Rye, I find her remarks disgusting and I am grossly offended by her use of “Jew-baiting”, when one considers the racist policies she presided over in the Home Office that has caused untold suffering to the Windrush generation and their families, it seems somewhat disingenuous to use defamatory accusations of anti-Semitism and the kind of language used against Jews in order to promote her own ambitions. Sorry Amber, but my Jewish heritage and it’s tragic history is not for you to use for your self-promotion.

  2. “Politics is a funny old game”, as one Tory was reported to have said. You have to wonder about the motives of a cabinet minister in a seat where the majority is tiny to the point of non-existent. As for Councillor Louise, she was happy, I assume to take all the offers of help from CLP volunteers for many hours to canvassing and leaflet delivery but then decided that the constituency is a hotbed of anti-Jewish sentiment. Like so many members I don’t recognise this as Hastings and Rother CLP. But politicians got to politic and given the dire position of Ms Rudd and his calamitous leader, you can hardly blame her for jumping on any passing bandwagon that might offer a few more votes when the Conservatives finally admit they are not fit to run the country.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Was 2018 the start of the Green trend in Hastings?

When the Green’s then co-leader Caroline Lucas visited Hastings for a bit of pre-election campaigning in 2018 she said that securing a Green councillor on Hastings Borough Council (HBC) would be a, “tremendous breakthrough” and “the start of a trend”. Last week, just six years later, the Greens became the biggest group on HBC. Listen […]

Public Inquiry to consider A21 level crossing at Robertsbridge opens next week

By this time next week the public inquiry into Rother Valley Railway’s (RVR) controversial planning application to construct a new heritage railway link between Bodiam and Robertsbridge as well as new level crossings – including one on the fast flowing A21 – will be underway. The inquiry will be led by Ian Jenkins, an inspector […]

Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /home2/hastings/domains/ on line 5420

Notice: ob_end_flush(): failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (1) in /home2/hastings/domains/ on line 5420